The danger of home country bias and how to avoid it

Home country bias occurs when investors concentrate their portfolios in shares and bonds from their home country.

For example, while the UK stock market now represents only 3.2% per cent of the value of global equity markets (in 2006, it was 10.4%), British investors tend to allocate considerably more than this to UK stocks.

It is a phenomenon that can often be detrimental to investment returns. Especially as the UK has lagged other world market in recent years.

What causes home country bias?

Whether consciously or not, investors tend to tilt their portfolios towards their home country. This typically happens due to one or more of a number of reasons:

Familiarity

We like to invest in things that we know.

In investing, what is comfortable is rarely profitable.

-Rob Arnott , founder and Chairman of Research Affiliates

Perception of risk

Due to factors such as corporate governance, investors perceive foreign investments as more risky than domestic ones.

Currency risk

Fluctuations in exchange rates can impact the return on foreign investments.

Personal experience

I have known clients invest in a company because a friend or family member works there.

They feel that this gives them an insight into the health of the company; we are less likely to have friends/family members working for a company in a country other than our own.

Employer pensions and share ownership plans

Employer pension schemes will typically be weighted heavily towards domestic assets. For example, a UK pension fund will typically invest heavily into UK stocks and bonds.

Then there are employer share ownership schemes. Expatriates often work for a company from our home country. Accumulating stock in them as part of your remuneration package increases your home country bias (the danger of being over exposed to shares in your employer is a subject for another day).

Multinational companies

Some investors rely on investing in domestic companies with a global presence as a means of diversification.

However, while multinational domestic companies do provide exposure to global markets, it is not the same as investing directly into those markets.

In fact, research from Vanguard suggests that the performance of a company’s shares tends to be highly correlated to its domestic market. This is irrespective of where it does most of its business.

Why does it matter?

As mentioned at the outset, home country bias at a minimum can be detrimental to a retirement plan and can often be far more damaging.

In fact, it has been shown that by avoiding broad global diversification, investors are actually increasing their risks.

This is because, in general, individual country markets are much less diversified than the global market.

The power of diversification

Instead, academic research strongly suggests that the foundation for long term investment growth is a globally diversified portfolio.

For example, in the chart below, the US ranked in the top five for annualized returns over the entire 20 years but finished first in the country rankings just once over that period. In nine calendar years, it was in the lower half of performers.

Meanwhile, in 2017, Austria posted the highest developed markets return but then followed that up with the lowest return the following year.

This just goes to show the power of diversification and not being overly reliant on one particular country (e.g. your home country).

Equity returns of developed markets

There is also the fact that different markets arbitrarily tilt towards different sectors. The U.S. for example has a high weighting towards technology stocks whereas the UK leans more towards financial and “old economy” firms and Canada has a predominance of mining and resource companies.

These sectors do not all move in the same way. If you are biased towards the UK and financial stocks perform poorly, then your portfolio will lag the global market.

It is hard to predict which sector will perform well over any time frame. Simply owning them all will reduce the risk of being overexposed to any one.

What to do about home country bias?

Many investors simply aren’t aware that they are overexposed to their home country.

The first step to solving the issue should be to drill down into the individual funds that you hold, enabling you to identify the underlying assets that are held within.

Once you know the weighting that you have to your home country, you can compare it to your country’s share of the world stock market. This will let you see if it is out of proportion.

The simplest solution if you suffer from this bias is to reinvest across all markets in proportion to their share of the overall world index. A global market-cap-weighted index fund would achieve this.

In doing so, you own the whole haystack instead of searching for the needle within.

For investors who have a crystal ball, portfolio diversification is unnecessary. For the rest of us a globally diversified portfolio tended to on a regular basis provides an opportunity to better handle the vagaries of volatile markets…

Abnormal Returns

Conclusion

By falling foul of home country bias, you may miss out on global opportunities.

For example, if you had invested in a global equity index (MSCI World GBP) over the last decade, you would have earned a return 13.53% pa.

By comparison, if you had invested in UK stocks (FTSE 100), then your return would be a fraction of that (3.4% pa).

Putting that into context, if you invested £100,000 and it grew by 13.53% per annum for 10 years, it would be worth £355,718. However, if you invested £100,000 and it grew by 3.34% per annum for 10 years, it would be worth £138,894. A difference of £216,824.

With a broadly diversified portfolio, you will reduce both the volatility of your returns and the risk of being overexposed to a specific country or sector. Thus allowing you to be more confident in your plans for retirement.

Further reading

Shall I compare thee to the global equity market?]

Some considerations for investing globally

How to revive Britains stock market

---